Chlorinated paraffins
Entry into the marine environment
Chlorinated paraffins (CPs), identified collectively
under the CAS number 63449-39-8, are chlorinated
linear hydrocarbons with between 10 and 30 carbon
atoms. They contain varying numbers of chlorine
atoms, with a maximum of one chlorine per carbon.
There are an array of commercially available CPs
with each CP corresponding to a mixture of isomers
and congeners whose carbon skeletons belong to one
of three main groups (in terms of chain length)
C10-13, C14-17, C18-26. Commercial CPs are usually
identified by a trade name followed by a number
reflecting the chlorine percentage. Commercial products
have a chlorine content of 40 - 70% (Hardie 1964,
cited in Howard et al 1975).
CPs are physically homogeneous, viscous yellowish
liquids or low melting solids. They are described
as having a colour ranging from light amber to yellow
(the actual shade will depend on the storage conditions
and the manufacturing process with the colour darkening
with prolonged heating due to the evolution of hydrogen
chloride gas) and a slightly unpleasant odour due
to the presence of small quantities of lower molecular
weight products. CPs with a chlorine content higher
than 40% are non-flammable, while those with a lower
chlorine percentage will burn with difficulty (Mukherjee
1990).
CPs have similar properties to polychlorinated
biphenyls (PCBs), although not as thermally stable,
and have replaced PCB compounds in many applications
(Howard et al 1975). Chlorinated paraffins
have a variety of uses, depending on the carbon
chain length. Short chain chlorinated paraffins
(C10-13) are used as lubricants, additives and sealants,
medium chain length (C14-17) as secondary PVC plasticisers
and long chain length (C20-30) in paints, lubricants
and additives (Campbell and McConnell 1980).
At present, the main uses of chlorinated paraffins
are as fire retardants and secondary plasticisers.
Secondary plasticisers are used as a substitute
for primary plasticisers, such as phthalates, usually
through cost considerations. However, the addition
of chlorinated paraffins to PVC, for example, also
provides flame retardancy whilst maintaining the
low temperature properties, e.g. strength of the
plastic. Chlorinated paraffins are also used as
an additive in cutting oils to improve the surface
roughness of the cutting surface.
In the UK, the manufacture of CPs is presently
carried out by ICI Chemicals and Polymers Group.
ICI has stated that the bulk of their Cereclor production
in Europe, some 80 KT annually, is in the UK (approximately
50KT). Of this, about 70% is exported (BRE 1992).
The major source of environmental contamination
is more likely to be via the use or disposal of
products containing CPs. CPs have a very low volatility
and are therefore not expected to be present at
any significant level in the atmosphere, although
minor inputs into the atmosphere from secondary
plasticisers (where the CPs are not chemically bound
up into plastics and are thus able to volatilise
to some extent) and flame retardant applications
may occur.
Chlorinated paraffin containing products such as
plastics, building materials and oils are likely
to be disposed of in dumps or landfills and, to
a lesser extent, by incineration. Due to the relatively
low thermal stability of CPs, the latter process
should result in the destruction of CP material.
Removal of CPs in landfills due to leaching is likely
to be slow due to their low water solubility and
their high log Kows which infers that CPs becoming
dispersed in the environment will tend to be adsorbed
onto solids and sediments, thus reducing their availability
for uptake by biota. Madeley and Birtley (1980)
predicted that the main input of CPs to the aquatic
environment was likely to remain adsorbed to the
sediment.
It can be concluded that there is unlikely to be
a significant input of CPs into the aquatic environment
from the atmosphere or via leaching from landfills.
Instead, entry is more likely to originate from
direct emissions into the aquatic environment via
industrial and sewage treatment plant effluents
in areas where CPs are used.
Recorded levels in the marine
environment
Investigations into the environmental concentrations
of CPs are currently limited to old studies carried
out by Campbell and McConnell (1980).
Campbell and McConnell (1980) investigated the
concentration of CPs in the environment and reported
concentrations for marine and freshwaters and sediment,
using a thin-layer chromatographic technique. This
technique enabled the authors to differentiate between
CPs of C10-20 and C20-30 chain length but not between
45 and 52% chlorination, nor between C10-13 or C14-17
chain length.
In UK marine waters, CP concentrations were found
in the range non-detected to 4 µg l-1
for C10-20 CPs and not detected to 2 µg
l-1 for C20-C30 CPs. CP concentrations
in marine sediments from coinciding sites were in
the range not detected to 0.5 mg l-1 for
C10-20 CPs and not detected to 0.6 mg l-1 for
C20-30 CPs. CP levels in non-marine waters, freshwaters
and sediments in industry free areas ranged from
0-1 µg l-1 of either
CP type. While 65% of samples contained no CPs (almost
twice that found for seawaters), when CPs were detected,
levels were close to that found in marine waters.
Sediment levels in freshwater were also found to
be comparable with marine sediments.
Campbell and McConnell (1980) also reported CP
concentrations in UK waters and sediments receiving
industrial/domestic effluents. CP levels in water
were found to be 1-6 µg l-1 and
1-10 mg l-1 in sediments (CPs of C10-20
chain length predominated).
Campbell and McConnell (1980) investigated CP concentrations
in plaice Pleuronectes platessa pouting Trisopterua
luscus mussel Mytilis edulis pike Esox
lucius and the liver and blubber of grey seal
Halichorus grypus. C20-30 CPs were barely
detectable in tissues (a maximum of 0.2 mg/kg) and
CPs of C20-30 were seen only at 0.4 mg/kg in organisms
from waters not receiving effluent from CP plant
effluents. However, mussels from water receiving
a CP manufacturing plant effluent had, in general,
concentrations of up to 1 mg/kg C10-20 CPs with
concentrations of 6 - 12 mg/kg close to the effluent
discharge.
When comparing sediment CP levels with aquatic
organism tissue levels, Campbell and McConnell (1980)
found little or no accumulation. Tissue levels were
found to be similar to those in the sediment near
where organisms lived. In addition, the authors
found no indication of biomagnification in any food
chain, aquatic or on land, including the human food
chain.
Fate and behaviour in the marine
environment
Since CPs are heterogeneous (i.e. a particular
sample may contain from ten to one hundred different
molecular species), the chemical properties of CPs
are the average of the chemical properties of the
different molecules. The properties vary with the
nature of the paraffinic raw materials, the temperature
of chlorination and the chlorine content.
Chlorinated paraffins are virtually insoluble in
water and lower alcohols but partially soluble in
higher alcohols, such as octanol. They are stable
mixtures but can undergo slow hydrolysis or dehydrochlorination
in aqueous solution. When subjected to high temperature,
the substances release HCl. Commercial CPs are often
stabilised against decomposition by the addition
of small quantities of substances that can act as
acid acceptors. The high log Kow values for chlorinated
paraffins (Lyman 1982, cited in Mukherjee 1990),
calculated log Kows in the range of 5.06 or a CP
of formula C10 H18 Cl4 to 12.68 for a CP of formula
C26 H44 Cl10) suggest that they will adsorb onto
sediments rather than remain in water.
Under ambient and neutral conditions, CPs hydrolyse
very slowly (Howard et al 1975). The short
chain CPs (C10-13) appear to be rapidly degraded
by acclimatised micro-organisms. Sewage treatment
organisms also brought about significant breakdown
of these short chain CPs. For longer chain paraffins
chlorinated up to 45%, the biodegradation, although
slower and reduced, indicated substantial breakdown
by acclimatised organisms. Similarly, a wax-grade
CP (C20-30, 42% Cl w/w) was also degraded when organisms
were previously acclimatised.
It can be concluded that chlorinated paraffins
are chemically stable under ambient temperatures
and will not undergo hydrolysis, photolysis or oxidation
at any significant rate. Micro-organisms have been
found to biodegrade chlorinated paraffins and acclimatisation
increases the ability of micro-organisms to degrade
long chain CPs. However, the longer the carbon chain
in the molecule and the greater the percentage of
chlorination, the more recalcitrant the compound.
In view of the highly complex composition of CPs,
it is difficult to distinguish between desirable
(i.e. straight chain derivatives) ingredients and
structurally related compounds (a factor that may
be important when investigating the ecotoxicity
of these compounds). However, while few investigations
into the presence of such impurities have been conducted,
available information indicates that their presence
is only likely at low concentrations. Stabilisers
are frequently added to CPs to inhibit decomposition,
especially when the product is intended for elevated
temperature use. Stabilisers used cover a wide range
of compounds and include: hydrocarbons; alcohols;
ethers; epoxy compounds; organometallic compounds;
organic nitrogen compounds, and inorganic compounds
(Svanberg 1983).
Effects on the marine environment
Toxicity to marine organisms
An exhaustive literature review on the toxicity
of chlorinated paraffins to marine organisms has
not been carried out for the purposes of this profile.
The information provided in this section is taken
from existing review documents (BRE 1992). The most
sensitive groups of organisms have been identified.
Data on the toxicity of chlorinated paraffins to
marine organisms indicate that toxicity increases
as the chain size decreases. High sensitivity is
exhibited by marine invertebrates and fish exposed
to short chain molecules.
Invertebrates
Tarkpea et al (1981 cited in Svanberg 1983)
reported that the harpacticoid Nitocra spinipes
appeared more sensitive to short chain than long
chain CPs. Reported 96 hour LC50s for short chain
CPs range from 0.06 - 9 mg l-1, while
for long chain CPs, the 96 hour LC50s are >1,000
mg l-1.
Madeley and Birtley (1980) found no significant
mortality in mussels fed for 47 days with dry yeast
contaminated with 524 µg/g (dry weight)
of Cereclor 42.
Fish
Svanberg et al (1978) reported sublethal
effects in bleak Alburnus alburnus when exposed
over a 14 day period to 1.0 and 0.1 microg l-1
of Huls chloparaffin 70C (C10-13, 70%Cl w/w) (added
to the test water from acetone solution). Fish showed
signs of disorientation and tetanic spasm which
may have led to the death of three individuals.
Linden et al (1979) also investigated the
acute toxicity (96 hour) of CPs to bleak. The tests
were carried out under static conditions in brackish
water (7 ppt). No renewal, aeration or control analysis
of the test solutions was carried out. Nine different
trade name CPs were tested, with carbon lengths
ranging from C10 - C26 and chlorine percentage ranging
from 42 to 71. All 96 hour LC50 were greater than
5,000 mg l-1.
Haux et al (1982) reported the effects of
the CP preparations Witachlor 149 (C12, 49% chlorine
w/w) and Hulz 70C (C12, 70% chlorine w/w) on the
haematology, osmoregulation, ionic regulation, intermediary
metabolism, hepatic mixed-function oxidase system
and steroid metabolising enzymes in male and female
flounder Platichthys flesus L. in brackish
and marine water. CPs were administered orally via
a stomach tube. The fish were fed twice (day 1 and
day 4) to obtain a total exposure of 1,000 mg kg-1
body weight of each CP. Sampling was at 13
and 27 days after the first administration of CP.
Witachlor 149 and Hulz 70C caused some sublethal
effects, mainly on the haematology, glucose metabolism
and xenobiotic and steroid metabolising enzymes
of female fish. However, the authors were unable
to interpret the physiological and ecological significance
of these findings.
Bioaccumulation
Svanberg et al (1978) investigated the bioaccumulation
of Chlorparaffin Huls 70C in bleak. The fish were
exposed to concentrations of 0.1 or 1.0 mg CPl-1
under semi-static conditions at 10°C
in brackish waters (7 ppt) (test solutions were
renewed every two or three days). During the experiment,
individual fish exhibited signs of neurotoxic effects
at the dose of 1 mg CPl-1 after 14 days
and some mortality occurred at both concentrations.
The whole body chlorine content indicated that the
CP was taken up but the uptake did not appear to
differ significantly between the two concentrations.
After 29 days, the mean whole body chlorine content
(wet weight) of fish exposed to 0.1 mg CPl-1
was 26.2 microg Cl g-1 and 28.6
µg Cl g-1 for fish exposed
to 1.0 mg Cl l.-1.
Svanberg (1983) reported some unpublished observations
of Tarkpea and Renberg (1982). Mussels Mytilus
edulis accumulated 14C-labelled C16-chloro-alkane
when exposed via water, resulting in a bioconcentration
factor of about 6,000.
Campbell and McConnell (1980) concluded from investigations
into levels of CPs found in the environment that
there was no evidence to suggest that aquatic organisms
accumulated CPs to levels above those found in nearby
sediments. The authors also concluded that there
was no evidence of CP biomagnification through the
food chain. However, it appears that CPs of low
molecular weight maybe accumulated while those of
high molecular weight are not. Madeley and Birtley
(1980) proposed that CPs of high molecular weight
would be limited in their potential for bioaccumulation
in the aquatic environment due to their low water
solubility and because their strong tendency to
adsorb onto suspended particles would decrease their
availability to food-chain organisms. Zitko and
Arsenault (1974) concluded that the uptake of CPs
decreased or was completely inhibited when the molecular
weight of the CP exceeded 600 (this would correspond
to a carbon chain length of 24 and a chlorination
level just below 50%).
Potential effects on interest
features of European marine sites
Potential effects include:
- toxicity of chlorinated paraffins (especially
short chain, low molecular weight species) to
invertebrates and fish in the water column (there
is no EQS for chlorinated paraffins);
- accumulation in sediments and a largely unknown
potential for low molecular weight chlorinated
paraffins to bioaccumulate.
Next Section
References
|