|
Chlorophenols (CP) and Dichlorophenols (DCP)
Entry into the marine environment
The principal use of the monochlorinated phenols
is as intermediates in the synthesis of the higher
chlorinated congeners and certain dyes and pesticides.
The chief use of 2,4-DCP is as an intermediate in
the production of 2,4-D and other herbicides. 2,4-DCP
is also used as an ingredient in antiseptics (Grimwood
and Mascarenhas 1997).
The main route of entry of 2-, 3- and 4-CP and
2,4-DCP to the aquatic environment is likely to
be as a result of discharges from plants manufacturing
the compounds or from plants using the compounds
as intermediates in the production of higher chlorinated
phenols and other products, such as phenoxy herbicides.
Indirect sources include discharges from paper
mills, where they are formed as by-products of the
bleaching process, as a result of the disinfection
of sewage, industrial wastes and drinking water
with chlorine, and from the microbial breakdown
of agricultural herbicides such as 2,4-D and subsequent
run-off/leaching of the products.
Grimwood and Mascarenhas (1997) found that reliable
data on the production levels of chlorophenols other
than pentachlorophenol were not available in open
literature. In 1975, the combined global production
of all chlorophenols approached 200 million kilograms.
More than half consisted of chlorophenols other
than PCP, with 2,4-DCP, 2,4,5-TCP and 2,3,4,6-TCP
predominating (WHO 1989). Krijgsheld and van der
Gen (1986, cited in WHO 1989) reported European
production levels of 4.5 and 9.1 million kilograms
for total monochlorophenols and 2,4-DCP respectively
(year not stated), while in 1972, total chlorophenol
production in the UK was reported to be 1.14 million
Recorded levels in the marine
environment
Data for 2-CP from the South-West Region of the
Environment Agency over the monitoring period 1992
to 1995 indicated that the great majority of concentrations
at sites associated with routine monitoring in fresh
and saltwaters were less than 0.2 microg l-1.
Residues of all chlorophenol isomers have been
detected in aquatic systems (WHO 1989). Generally,
residues are present at measurable concentrations
in discharges from such sources as manufacturing
plants, wood-treatment facilities, municipal waste
discharges and in receiving waters adjacent to these
sources. Concentrations in other surface waters
are more sporadic and usually low, although some
isomers have been detected in some of the world's
cleanest waters (WHO 1989).
These values are supported by the limited data
reported in various other studies. For example,
2-CP, 3-CP and 4-CP have been detected at µg
l-1 levels in effluents from European
sewage treatment plants and cooling water from power
stations as a result of disinfection by chlorination
(cited in WHO 1989), while in coastal areas and
in rivers flowing through industrialised regions
of the Netherlands, Piet and deGrunt (1975, cited
in WHO 1989) reported that concentrations of monochlorophenols
ranged from not-detected up to 20 microg l-1
and dichlorophenols from not-detected up to 1.5
microg l-1.
Chlorophenol concentrations in sediments are generally
higher than in overlying water. This may be as a
result of adsorption onto suspended solids in the
water column and subsequent sedimentation. However,
very few data are available for mono- and dichlorophenols.
At a site 2 km distant from a sulphate pulp mill,
sediments in the Baltic sea were reported to contain
a 2,4-DCP concentration of 0.9 µg kg-1
(Xie 1983, cited in WHO 1989), while in a later
survey, the same authors reported a sediment concentration
of 16 microg kg-1 2 km from the discharge
and 0 microg kg-1 5-10 km from the discharge.
Fate and behaviour in the marine
environment
Despite the high solubility of these compounds,
some adsorption to the organic carbon content of
aquatic sediments may occur as indicated by the
moderate octanol-water (Kow) partition coefficients.
However, the high solubilities and lower organic-carbon
coefficients (Koc) for some soils, suggest that
the lower chlorinated phenols may be susceptible
to leaching to surface and ground waters. The low
Henry=s Law Constants for these compounds suggest
that volatilisation from surface waters is not likely
to be an important removal route (Grimwood and Mascarenhas
1997).
Since chlorophenols are weak acids in aqueous solution,
one of the major factors affecting environmental
transport, degradation and toxicity is the degree
to which the compounds are dissociated in natural
waters. Under acidic conditions, chlorophenols exist
primarily in the toxic molecular (undissociated)
form, while under basic conditions, the dissociated
form predominates. The pKa values (pH at which an
acid compound is 50% dissociated) of 2-, 3- and
4-CP and 2,4-DCP indicate that at the pH range characterising
most physiological and environmental conditions,
these compounds will exist predominately in the
more active undissociated form. Furthermore, as
pH decreases, the proportion of molecules in the
undissociated state will increase further, leading
to yet higher activity as shown by parameters, such
as adsorption to suspended solids and sediments
and toxicity.
Chlorophenols are susceptible to photolysis and
biodegradation. Photolysis is only expected to be
an important process near the surface of water bodies
(particularly in summer months). In deeper waters
and sediments, aerobic and anaerobic biodegradation
will be the main route of removal for chlorophenols.
Photolysis of polychlorinated phenols appears to
be higher than for monochlorinated congeners. Respective
summer/winter half-lives for complete photomineralisation
(i.e. breakdown to CO2) of 6/14 and 53/334
days have been reported for 2,4-DCP and 4-CP in
estuarine samples (Hwang and Hodson 1986). The higher
rates in summer were attributed to higher irradiance
in this season.
2-, 3-, 4-CP and 2,4-DCP all undergo microbial
degradation under aerobic conditions via oxidative
dechlorination and hydroxylation. Biodegradation
is more rapid in sediments (and soils) as a result
of more complex/active microbial communities and
more favourable environmental conditions in these
media (e.g. organic matter content, nutrient status,
pH, etc.). The data also suggest that aerobic biodegradation
is less rapid for meta- (3-) and para-
(4-) substituted compounds and for the highly chlorinated
congeners. This pattern is more apparent on an observation
of the whole chlorophenol series from the mono-
compounds through the di-, tri- and tetrachlorophenols
up to pentachlorophenol. In addition, there is often
a lag period associated with chlorophenol biodegradation
in water and sediment. Such lag periods are usually
attributed to the period required by resident micro-organisms
to become physiologically acclimated to toxic compounds
or to the period in which small populations of resident
DCP degraders increases to large enough numbers,
such that DCP biodegradation becomes detectable.
In the water column and sediments of aquatic ecosystems,
aerobic biodegradation half-lives of 2-36 days have
been reported for the monochlorinated congeners
at ambient temperatures. Corresponding values of
70-100% biodegradation of 2,4-DCP in 10-30 days
have been reported. Some of these values may also
incorporate removal by photolysis. Indeed, respective
half-lives in estuarine water samples that account
for both photolysis and microbial degradation of
4-CP and 2,4-DCP, have been reported to be 10/95
and 4/17 days in summer/winter, respectively.
Under anaerobic conditions in aquatic sediments,
chlorophenols are biodegraded by reductive dechlorination
(progressive replacement of the chlorines by hydrogen),
usually by a consortium of several different microbial
species. Under these conditions, meta- (3-)
and para- (4-) substituted congeners appear
to be more resistant to biodegradation. Moreover,
in the complete mineralisation (i.e. reductive dechlorination
to methane) of the higher chlorinated congeners,
the breakdown of 4-CP is the rate limiting step.
This is shown by values for complete biodegradation
of 28-30, 15-61, 61 and 90 days for 2-CP, 3-CP,
4-CP and 2,4-DCP respectively. As with aerobic biodegradation,
a lag period is usually associated with anaerobic
biodegradation in aquatic sediments.
Effects on the marine environment
Toxicity to marine organisms
An exhaustive literature review on the toxicity
of chlorophenols and dichlorophenols to marine organisms
has not been carried out for the purposes of this
profile. The information provided in this section
is taken from existing review documents (Grimwood
and Mascarenhas 1997). The most sensitive groups
of organisms have been identified.
Grimwood and Mascarenhas (1997) reviewed the data
on the aquatic toxicity and concluded that saltwater
data were considerably more limited than for freshwater
organisms, but also that no one group of organisms
was more sensitive than any other group. The majority
of reported L(E)C50 data ranging from 0.6-19.5,
2.55-29.7 and 5-7 mg l-1 for algae, crustaceans
and fish, respectively, indicating moderate to high
acute toxicity. These data mainly represent 4-CP
and 2,4-DCP, with 2- and 3-CP data for fish only.
The only long-term exposure data available for saltwater
organisms relate to a mesocosm study conducted under
field conditions in which a 4-CP and 2,4-DCP concentration
of 1.0 mg l-1 was found to cause severe
inhibition of growth and biomass of natural phytoplankton
communities (mixed species) (Kuiper and Hanstevit
1984).
The lowest reported toxicity data for 4-CP include
5-day NOECs, of 0.39 (total cell volume) and 1.08
(total cell count) mg l-1 for the diatom
Skeletonema costatum (Cowgill et al
1989), and a 96 hour NOEC (mortality) of 3.2 mg
l-1 for juveniles of sheepshead minnow
Cyprinodon variegatus, while the lowest reported
data for 2,4-DCP include a 96-hour LC50 and a 72-hour
EC50 (growth) of 2.55 and 0.6 mg l-1
for the grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio and
diatom Phaeodactylum tricornutum respectively
(Rao et al 1981, cited in WHO 1989 and Kusk
and Nyholm 1992). Toxicity data for 2- and 3-CP
are limited to just one or two fish values, with
the lowest being 96-hour LC50s of 6.6 and 4.0 mg
l-1 for sole Solea solea and flounder
Platichthys flesus respectively (Smith et
al 1994).
In fish, polychlorophenols appear to be Type II
'polar' narcotics. In other words, compounds that
cause narcosis associated with a specific mode of
action. This has been identified as an uncoupling
of electron transport (oxidative phosphorylation)
in mitochondria. However, the mechanism of toxicity
in invertebrates and of the monochlorophenols appears
to be less specific (Grimwood and Mascarenhas 1997).
The toxicity of chlorophenols to aquatic organisms
rises with increasing degree of chlorination and
substitution away from the ortho- (2-) position.
The higher toxicity of the more highly chlorinated
congeners can be ascribed to an increase in lipophilicity
which leads to a greater potential for uptake into
the organism. Ortho-substituted congeners
are generally of lower toxicity than the meta-
and para- substituted compounds, as the close
proximity of the ortho-substituted chlorine
to the OH group on the molecule appears to 'shield'
the OH, which apparently interacts with the active
site in aquatic organisms, causing the observed
toxic effects (Grimwood and Mascarenhas 1997).
Toxicity also depends on the extent to which the
chlorophenol molecules are dissociated in the exposure
medium, with increased toxicity observed with a
decrease in pH. This is because the more toxic non-dissociated
form predominates at lower pH, while at higher pH,
the less toxic dissociated form is predominant.
Moreover, the pKa values of 2-, 3- and 4-CP and
2,4-DCP indicate that at the pH range characterising
most environmental conditions, these compounds will
exist predominately in the more active non-dissociated
form.
No data could be located for sediment dwelling
organisms.
Bioaccumulation
Grimwood and Mascarenhas (1997) concluded that
the vast majority of aquatic organisms did not readily
accumulate monochlorophenols or 2,4-DCP to high
levels, with BCFs in fish ranging from 3.8-34.0
at neutral pH, and depuration half-lives in the
order of hours to days. Since toxicity is directly
linked to bioaccumulation, Grimwood and Mascarenhas
(1997) also concluded that all the issues concerning
the effects of degree of chlorination and dissociation
on the toxicity of chlorophenols, also related to
the uptake and bioaccumulation of these compounds.
Therefore, an observation of bioaccumulation data
for the whole chlorophenol series would show that
the higher chlorinated congeners (e.g. tri-, tetra-
and PCP) are accumulated to higher levels, with
BCFs ranging from 102-103.
Potential effects on interest
features of European marine sites
Potential effects include:
- toxicity of 2-chlorophenol to algae, invertebrates
and fish at concentrations above the EQS of 50
microg l-1 (annual average) and 250
microg l-1 (maximum allowable concentration)
in the water column;
- toxicity of 2-4-dichlorophenol to algae, invertebrates
and fish at concentrations above the EQS of 20
microg l-1 (annual average) and 140
microg l-1 (maximum allowable concentration)
in the water column.
- potential for bioaccumulation for the higher
chlorinated (tri-, tetra- and pentachlorophenol)
compounds in the series.
Next Section
|